Concert Review:

Dream Theater
Live at the Warfield Theater 03/09/02
San Francisco, CA


For a variety of reasons I had never had much exposure to Dream Theater prior to witnessing them live at the Warfield on their current "World Tourbulence" tour, despite the fact that I've long been a fan of the "progressive metal" genre. So one question kept popping into my head during the show: "Where the hell have I been?"

Over the course of 3 hours (!) of brilliant music, played with an expert precision like I hadn't seen in years, I became a Dream Theater fan. And while I'm sure there's a lot of old-school fans out there who'll tell me I arrived at the party way too late, judging by this show and their stellar new double CD Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence it seems that I've "discovered" DT at just the right time.

They open with "The Glass Prison", the thundering opening track from the new CD. Or should I say the thundering 14-minute opening track from their new CD. While the CD version rocks, I'm immediately floored by just how intense the song comes off live. Guitar wunderkind John Petrucci tears through the galloping Megadeth-style riff with effortless abandon. Right out of the gate, the mix sounds superb, especially the rhythm section of drummer Mike Portnoy and bassist John Myung, but once my ears adjust to the volume it seems that Petrucci's guitar could stand to be a little more prominent. (At times his guitar tended to be overwhelmed by Jordan Rudess's keyboards). And although James LaBrie's vocals don't quite measure up to the studio polish of the CD, he's generally able to nail all his trademark screams and high notes, but perhaps without all the electronically-assisted sustain you hear on record.

 

So I've already made one band reference (Megadeth) to try and describe the feel of DT live, but throughout the course of the show (did I mention they played for 3 hours?!) I hear so many passages that instantly recall other bands that I can't scribble them down fast enough. There are the obvious ones that have been well documented, like Rush, Yes, and Zeppelin, but a big one for me is Marillion, especially the classic Fish-era of Fugazi and Misplaced Childhood. Petrucci's soaring guitar reminds me several times of Marillionıs Steve Rothery, especially during the frequent interplay with Rudess's keyboards. Other times Petrucci channels David Gilmour's leads, and on the heavier side I hear some of the aforementioned Dave Mustaine, and of course they canıt hide the Metallica influence.

None of this is to say DT is a derivative band. On the contrary there's really no other band out there thatıs doing what they're doing today. There's no one that combines 70s-style keyboard-driven progressive rock with really heavy metal, and certainly not with the technical mastery that these five gifted musicians bring to the table. When it's really clicking it's a fabulous combination, providing aggression and melody in spades. But it has to be said that on a few occasions the band lets the "progressive" side run a little wild and the result is a couple of what I would charitably describe as slow points. But in a 3-hour show there are going to be some lulls, no matter who the band is, so let's just ignore those and concentrate on the many high points.

After the opening "Prison" we get a whole slew of older songs: "Strange Deja vu," "Surrounded," "Burning my Soul," and "Killing Hand" Of those "Surrounded," from 1992's Images and Words, is a particular standout. LaBrie's singing really carries this one, giving an already powerful song even more emotional muscle than the album version, and once again I keep thinking of Marillion, albeit a much heavier Marillion. Next is another 14-minute epic off Turbulence, "The Great Debate," about the controversy surrounding stem cell research. Although a fine song, there's clearly a lull somewhere around the 7th or 8th minute ­ you can feel the crowd's energy dip a notch or two.

 

Luckily, the final song of the first set, "Take the Time," also from Images and Words, gets things emphatically back in gear. While their rendition is lights out, itıs not until Petrucci's solo that things get really interesting, as the band seamlessly segues into a wicked Rush medley that includes the ending movements of both "Working Man" and "By-Tor and the Snowdog." Petrucci just goes off ­ he's Alex Lifeson in 1975, just without the flowing robes and platform boots. I'm shaking my head, just a phenomenal performance so far.

After a 20-minute intermission they get right down to business again, going through the entire 42-minute Inner Turbulence title suite, Dream Theaterıs answer to 2112. From the circus-like feel of the overture (I'm reminded of the Main Street Electric Parade at Disneyland) to the grinding metal of "The Test That Stumped Them All" to the Styx-like "Solitary Shell," (which has a Fooling Yourself vibe), itıs 42 minutes of musical bliss.

How are they going to top that? The 11-minute "Scarred" kicks off the encores, then comes "Home" and the recent ballad "The Spirit Carries On," which becomes another LaBrie showcase. The power ballad is really a lost art (for better or for worse) but perhaps Dream Theater will be the band to resurrect it. However you want to classify it, "Spirit" is simply a wonderful song, and quite an interesting lead-in to the final song of the night, which is also the heaviest song of the night. "Pull Me Under" was their breakthrough song in 1992, the lead track from Images and Words, and the Warfield crowd was pumped for it. Once again, Petrucci just takes over. He's a virtuoso talent, yet he doesn't let his playing overwhelm the songs, nor does he ever intentionally outshine his bandmates (who are all virtuosos in their own right). And as a result of his recent G3 collaboration with Steve Vai and Joe Satriani, Petrucci's talent is now reaching an even wider audience. And speaking of Satch, the Bay Area guitar god was seen enjoying tonight's show from the Warfield balcony.

 

It's no surprise that DT doesn't simply go through a by-the-book rendition of "Pull Me Under," as halfway through the song they once again pay homage to another influence, and in dramatic fashion. In the blink of an eye a large backdrop unfurls above Mike Portnoy's drum kit and the crowd goes mental when they see the cover of Metallica's Master of Puppets album, only with the words Dream Theater (in the Metallica font!) across the top. As soon as everyone realizes that they are actually playing "Master of Puppets," starting from the mellow midsection, it's sheer pandemonium. Petrucci starts off with his back to the audience, the better to show the audience his "Metallica ­ San Francisco" T-shirt. Their version is electrifying, and flawless (LaBrie can certainly be forgiven for not sounding a bit like James Hetfield!) This is a band that really understands how a perfectly executed, well-placed cover song can put a show over the top. After they take MOP all the way home, they jump right back into the final bars of "Pull me Under" and the show comes to a sudden but satisfying end.

And again I ask myself, "Where have I been?"

-Peter Cole

Dream Theater setlist:

The Glass Prison
Strange Deja vu
Surrounded
Burning My Soul
Another Hand/Killing Hand
The Great Debate
Another Dimension?
Lines in the Sand Take the Time (Working Man/By-Tor and the Snow Dog)

Intermission

Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence Encores:

Scarred
Home
The Spirit Carries On
Pull Me Under (Master of Puppets)